#117: The Billion Dollar Reason Schools Still Aren’t Teaching Kids to Read with Mary McCool Berry
Someone Like Her Should Be Out of Business
Mary McCool Berry has spent 38 years helping students learn to read but she wants to go out of business.
Right now, her students with dyslexia meet with her before school and after school. They spend their winter breaks and summer breaks with her, too.
Mary loves those students. But she told me something I haven’t been able to stop thinking about:
“Someone like me should be out of business.”
Every one of those students should be getting this help at school, during the school day.
Instead, Mary says, a billion dollar tutoring market has grown up around dyslexia. Families who can pay get their kids reading.
And the families who can’t?
Their kids sit in our classrooms, guessing at words and quietly wondering what’s wrong with them.
We’ve had the research for decades. We know what works.
So why isn’t it happening?
The more Mary and I talked, the clearer the answer got. And it made me mad.
A lot of it comes down to money.
Why This Matters So Much
Mary learned about dyslexia in 2010 from a family whose son was moving up grade after grade without learning to read. She had a master’s degree in reading. She still didn’t know how to help him.
Then she looked back and realized there had been so many students just like him.
When students with dyslexia don’t get the right help, the cost is real. They’re often bright and capable. They watch their friends “get it” while they can’t, and the shame can follow them for years.
So much of what looks like misbehavior is really a cry for help.
If you’ve ever had a student who just wasn’t clicking, no matter what you tried, please hear this. You’re not failing. You were simply never given the training this takes.
Here are three places Mary sees money getting in the way, and what you can do about each one.
Reason 1: Families Are Paying for What Schools Should Provide
Mary’s magic wand wish is simple. She wants every student with dyslexia to work with a trained specialist during the school day, five days a week.
We already do this for speech. Students who need speech therapy see a credentialed speech-language pathologist at school. Mary wants dyslexia to work the same way.
Right now, it usually doesn’t. So the help goes to whoever can afford it.
Try this:
- When a student’s behavior changes during reading time, look at reading first. Frustration often shows up as acting out or shutting down.
- Keep simple notes on how that student is reading over time. A few weeks of notes tells a clearer story than one bad day.
- Share what you’re seeing with your team early. The sooner someone asks questions, the sooner that student gets help.
Pro Tip: You can’t fix the whole system on your own. But you can make sure the student in front of you doesn’t fall through the cracks.
Reason 2: “Science of Reading” Is a Label Anyone Can Sell
This one surprised a lot of people.
According to Mary, no one oversees the phrase “science of reading.” There’s no trademark and no agency that checks it. A publisher, a consultant, or a PD company can put it on their materials, even if those materials only partly match the research.
And there’s big money in it. When I first found out that publishing companies have lobbyists working in Washington and in state capitols on reading instruction, it blew my mind. Mary agreed. When she left the classroom, she had no idea how much money was involved in education. It scared her.
She also shared that when Ohio’s dyslexia guidebook went to lawmakers for final review, they wanted certain things taken out. The people who wrote it were specialists with decades of experience.
Her message to decision-makers? Trust the science, and trust the professionals who do this work every day.
Try this:
When your school offers a new program or intervention, ask Mary’s four questions:
- What kind of intervention are students getting?
- How often do they get it?
- Who is teaching it, and what training do they have?
- How is progress shared with parents?
Pro Tip: A label on the box can’t tell you much. Those four questions tell you a lot.
Reason 3: Training Money Goes Everywhere Else
Mary pointed out that schools spend millions of dollars training teachers in positive behavior programs. Calm, kind classrooms matter! But she asked a great question. Why not spend some of that money training teachers to teach students with dyslexia?
If students learn to read, so many of those behaviors fade away. In Mary’s words, that’s getting to the root cause.
She told me something else that stuck with me. She reached out to the university where she earned her degree and asked what they were doing to prepare teachers for dyslexia. Nothing. They were putting their money into a new nursing program instead.
So teachers end up with a webinar here and a workshop there. Mary says that’s not enough. Her own training included a practicum with an 88-point checklist, and she had to score perfectly on every single point!
In This Episode, You’ll Discover:
- Why Mary believes someone like her should be out of business
- How the dyslexia tutoring market leaves so many families behind
- Why a “science of reading” label doesn’t guarantee research-backed materials
- How money shapes the reading programs and training schools choose
- How teachers can speak up and be heard at the district and state level
Bringing It All Together
This conversation made me angry. Then it made me hopeful.
Mary is hopeful, too! When she left the classroom in 2019, hardly anyone was talking about dyslexia. Today, teachers everywhere are learning about it, often on their own time, because they care so much about the faces in front of them.
That’s where real change starts.
If you’re a teacher who’s struggling, you are not broken. Your students are not broken. You just needed clearer tools.
Want More Support? Join The Science of Reading Formula
Inside The Science of Reading Formula, you’ll get research-backed, done-for-you tools and training, with everything in one place. No more guessing what to do for the student who isn’t clicking.
If you’re ready to stop piecing it together and feel confident helping every reader in your room…
👉 Join The Science of Reading Formula
LINKS
International Dyslexia Association
Dyslexia Nation by Mary McCool Berry (coming soon)
Become a Science of Reading Formula member!
WHAT TO LISTEN TO NEXT
Rate, Review, and Follow
If you loved this episode, please take a minute to rate and review my show! That helps the podcast world know that this show is worth sharing with other educators just like you.
Click here, scroll to the bottom, tap to rate with five stars, and select “Write a Review”. Then let me know what you loved most about the episode!
While you’re there, be sure to follow the podcast. I’m adding a bunch of bonus episodes to the feed and I don’t want you to miss out! Follow right here.

