#112: How Structured Literacy Strategies Actually Help Struggling Readers with Dr. Louise Spear-Swerling
A Familiar Struggle in PreK-2 Classrooms
Ever had a student who could decode words decently but still couldn’t comprehend what they read? Or maybe you’ve worked with a first grader who seemed to shut down at every new word? If you’re nodding your head, you’re not alone.
So many veteran PreK-2 teachers are doing their absolute best, yet still feel stuck when it comes to helping their most at-risk readers. And often, it’s not a lack of effort — it’s a lack of training in what actually works.
In this episode of The Science of Reading Formula Podcast, expert Louise Spear-Swerling breaks down structured literacy strategies that actually help struggling readers — and why so many current interventions miss the mark. Whether you’re in the classroom, leading interventions, or coaching teachers, this episode offers a roadmap to move students forward with confidence.
What Is Structured Literacy — Really?
Structured literacy isn’t just a buzzword. According to Spear-Swerling, it’s an umbrella term that includes programs and methods with specific content (like phonemic awareness, phonics, vocabulary, and morphology) and a shared instructional approach: explicit, systematic, and supported with prompt feedback.
Let’s break that down a bit.
At its core, structured literacy includes these key components:
- Phonemic awareness – the ability to hear, identify, and manipulate individual sounds in words.
- Phonics – understanding the relationships between sounds and their written symbols.
- Oral vocabulary – helping students understand and use a wide range of words.
- Morphology – teaching students about prefixes, suffixes, and root words to support word recognition and meaning.
- Language comprehension – understanding spoken and written language at the sentence and passage level.
What makes it structured is how it’s taught:
- Explicitly – Teachers directly explain what students need to know.
- Systematically – Skills build from simple to complex.
- With frequent practice and feedback – So misunderstandings can be caught early and corrected.
And here’s the kicker: It’s not just for special education. Structured literacy helps all struggling readers, whether or not they have a diagnosis like dyslexia.
Why Some Students Don’t Progress — Even with Intervention
Many teachers have followed the “do what the program says” model for years, only to discover that students plateau or don’t transfer skills to real reading.
Here’s why that happens:
- Mismatch between needs and instruction. A student who has solid phonemic awareness may not benefit from an intervention that spends weeks reviewing that skill. If their core issue is phonics, they’re not getting what they actually need.
- No consistency between tiers. Spear-Swerling calls this “curriculum whiplash” — where a student learns one method in Tier 1 and something totally different in Tier 2 or 3. This confusion stalls progress and erodes confidence.
- Lack of data-driven instruction. Without informal assessments and weekly check-ins, it’s easy to miss whether an intervention is working… or not.
The solution? Tailor instruction using structured literacy strategies and keep it responsive with ongoing progress monitoring.
Actionable Strategies You Can Use Right Away
Louise offers practical, classroom-tested strategies that you can begin using this week — no new curriculum required.
1. Use Informal Assessments to Guide Your Teaching
You don’t need formal diagnostic tests to figure out what your students need. Tools like the Core Phonics Survey or downloadable CBMs (Curriculum-Based Measures) like DIBELS or Acadience help pinpoint gaps in phonics, fluency, or decoding. Just a few minutes can reveal whether a student has mastered CVC words, vowel teams, or digraphs — and what to teach next.
2. Monitor Progress Weekly
You don’t need to wait for benchmark windows. Quick, embedded checks during small-group instruction give real-time feedback. Can they segment sounds? Decode nonsense words? Retell a story? If not, adjust. One tweak at a time.
Tip: Keep it simple — even a sticky note checklist can help you spot patterns and plan next steps.
3. Prioritize What Matters Most
Spear-Swerling emphasizes the need to teach what’s urgent, not just what’s scheduled. For example, a student with major vocabulary gaps shouldn’t spend all their time labeling text features. Teach them the words they need to understand what they’re reading. That’s what moves comprehension forward.
4. Give Feedback That Builds Confidence
Many teachers avoid correcting students because they’re afraid of damaging self-esteem. But feedback, when delivered with kindness and clarity, is a powerful teaching tool. Try phrases like:
- “That one’s tricky — let’s look at it again together.”
- “You’re so close! Let’s tap it out one more time.”
This kind of supportive language keeps students engaged while helping them grow.
5. Watch for Instructional Mismatches
If your intervention includes weeks of phonemic awareness activities, but your student already passed all the phoneme segmentation checks, it’s time to pivot. Teach what they don’t know yet — not what the script says they should repeat.
6. Align Language and Methods Across Tiers
If Tier 1 uses one method and Tier 2 or 3 use something completely different, students get confused. For example, if classroom reading instruction encourages guessing words based on pictures, and Tier 2 emphasizes decoding, students may lean on old habits. Spear-Swerling recommends consistent language, strategies, and scope across all levels.
In This Episode, You’ll Discover:
- Why structured literacy is more than just phonics.
- The specific components that make it work for struggling readers.
- How to use informal data to drive instruction day by day.
- The most common instructional mismatches that slow progress.
- What to do when a student “stalls” in intervention.
- Myths about dyslexia — and what actually helps these students.
- How to create coherence across Tier 1, Tier 2, and Tier 3 instruction.
Bringing It All Together
Struggling readers aren’t “unreachable.” They just need instruction that’s informed, intentional, and responsive. Structured literacy gives you the tools to do just that — but like any tool, it works best in the hands of a teacher who knows how to use it.
Louise Spear-Swerling reminds us that great teaching is both an art and a science. When you match the right strategies to the right needs — and track what’s working — you give every student a fighting chance at becoming a confident, capable reader.
Want More Support? Join The Science of Reading Formula
If you’re ready to go deeper and get step-by-step guidance on what to teach, how to teach it, and when to adjust — this is for you.
👉 Join The Science of Reading Formula and get everything you need to confidently support your PreK-2 readers.
You don’t have to figure this out alone. Let’s make reading success possible — one student at a time.
LINKS
Become a Science of Reading Formula member!
WHAT TO LISTEN TO NEXT
Rate, Review, and Follow
If you loved this episode, please take a minute to rate and review my show! That helps the podcast world know that this show is worth sharing with other educators just like you.
Click here, scroll to the bottom, tap to rate with five stars, and select “Write a Review”. Then let me know what you loved most about the episode!
While you’re there, be sure to follow the podcast. I’m adding a bunch of bonus episodes to the feed and I don’t want you to miss out! Follow right here.
