#79: The Truth About the Top 5 Literacy Curriculums
The Wake-Up Call We Can’t Ignore
The most recent NAEP reading scores were a gut punch for educators. Twelfth-grade scores hit their lowest point since 1992, and nearly a third of seniors can’t demonstrate basic reading skills.
For teachers in PreK–2 classrooms, this news feels heavy. These are the students we once introduced to their first letters and sounds. If so many are struggling years later, it forces us to ask: Are our programs actually working?
While it’s tempting to blame screen time, social media, or even pandemic disruptions, those explanations don’t tell the whole story. If they did, every state would show the same decline. But that’s not what we see.
Some states—like Mississippi and Louisiana—have actually made steady gains in reading scores over the past decade. These students lived through the same pandemic and use the same devices as everyone else.
The difference isn’t the kids. It isn’t the parents. And it isn’t outside factors. The difference is the instruction. When these states shifted away from balanced literacy programs and invested in science-of-reading practices—daily phonemic awareness, systematic phonics, and decodable text—their scores climbed while others stagnated or fell. In other words, when we change how we teach, we change outcomes.
The Truth About the Top Five Literacy Curriculums
Across the country, many schools rely on programs that feel polished, familiar, and popular. But popularity doesn’t always equal effectiveness. The truth about the top five literacy curriculums is that many of them lean on outdated strategies:
- Guessing words from pictures or context clues
- Memorizing long lists of “sight words”
- Reading leveled texts that don’t match a student’s phonics skills
On the surface, kids may look like they’re reading. But underneath, they’re missing the strong decoding foundation they’ll need to grow into fluent, confident readers. By the time they reach upper elementary, those gaps are hard to ignore—and that’s exactly what the NAEP data is showing us.
What the Science of Reading Tells Us
The good news? We do know what works. The science of reading shows that children learn to read best when instruction includes:
- Phonemic awareness taught daily and explicitly
- Systematic phonics in a clear sequence
- Sound mapping instead of endless flashcards
- Decodable texts that match what students are learning
- Comprehension and knowledge building woven throughout
These aren’t just theories—they’re backed by decades of research in classrooms, cognitive science, and linguistics.
Five Essentials Every Curriculum Must Have
Here’s what it looks like when schools shift from outdated practices to science-backed instruction.
1. Phonemic Awareness
Students must learn to hear and work with sounds before they can connect them to letters. Just 5–10 minutes a day makes a huge impact. The Science of Reading Formula and Heggerty provide simple, ready-to-use routines for this.
Example: Students clap out the sounds in “cat” (/c/ /a/ /t/) before writing the word.
2. Systematic Phonics
Phonics instruction should follow a staircase—step by step, no skipping. UFLI and The Science of Reading Formula provide structured sequences so teachers always know what to teach next.
Example: After mastering short vowels, students move on to digraphs like “sh” or “ch.”
3. Sound Mapping
Instead of memorizing “sight words” by rote, students map sounds to letters. The Science of Reading Formula includes sound mapping lessons for high-frequency words.
Example: For “said,” students map /s/ → s, /e/ → ai, /d/ → d. The word sticks because it’s tied to sounds, not random memory.
4. Decodable Text
Kids need books that let them apply what they’ve learned—not guess at words they haven’t. The Science of Reading Formula offers decodable passages for every skill.
Example: After learning short a and short i, students read “Sam sat. Tim is in.” Every word is decodable, building true confidence.
5. Comprehension and Knowledge Building
Once decoding is secure, students need to grow as thinkers. The Science of Reading Formula balances comprehension and vocabulary with foundational skills so kids can make meaning from text.
Example: While studying animals, students can also learn science words like “habitat” and “predator” in context.
Filling the Gaps Without Starting Over
Here’s the encouraging part: if your school uses one of the top five literacy curriculums and it’s missing pieces, you don’t have to throw it away. You can fill the gaps with the right resources.
- Bring in The Science of Reading Formula for phonemic awareness, phonics, sound mapping, decodable texts, and comprehension.
- Add Heggerty for daily phonemic awareness.
- Use UFLI for systematic phonics lessons.
These tools strengthen what’s missing so students get the instruction research says they need.
In This Episode, You’ll Discover
- The truth about the top five literacy curriculums used in schools today
- Why guessing strategies like three-cueing and picture clues don’t work
- How NAEP reading scores highlight the urgent need for better instruction
- Five essential components every reading program must include
- Practical ways to fill curriculum gaps with Heggerty, UFLI, and The Science of Reading Formula
Why This Matters Now
The truth about the top five literacy curriculums is this: many of them are not aligned with how children actually learn to read. That’s why NAEP scores are flat or falling. But we don’t have to accept this.
When teachers replace guessing with decoding, sound mapping, and decodables, everything changes. Kids stop faking reading and start really reading. And the best part? Growth happens faster than most teachers expect.
Bringing It All Together
The data is clear. The old ways aren’t working, and students are paying the price. But with science-backed instruction, we can change the story.
Inside The Science of Reading Formula, you’ll find everything you need to bring this shift to life:
- Print-and-go phonics and phonemic awareness lessons
- Sound mapping routines for high-frequency words
- Decodable passages and centers for every skill
- Comprehension lessons that build vocabulary and knowledge
The truth about the top five literacy curriculums is that many of them leave big gaps. But with the right tools, you can fill those gaps—and give every child the gift of reading.
LINKS
The Nation’s Report Card (NAEP)
The Reading League Curriculum Reports
Become a Science of Reading Formula member!
WHAT TO LISTEN TO NEXT
Rate, Review, and Follow
If you loved this episode, please take a minute to rate and review my show! That helps the podcast world know that this show is worth sharing with other educators just like you.
Click here, scroll to the bottom, tap to rate with five stars, and select “Write a Review”. Then let me know what you loved most about the episode!
While you’re there, be sure to follow the podcast. I’m adding a bunch of bonus episodes to the feed and I don’t want you to miss out! Follow right here.
